Earlier this month, the cute couple were said to have called time on their relationship due to their busy work schedules.
However, over the weekend, TMZ reported that Selieber met up at a Los Angeles restaurant for reconciliation talks, with the pair leaving just minutes after arriving.
Sources have since claimed to E! Online that Justin and Selena left the AMAs, held at the Nokia Theatre in LA, hand-in-hand - fuelling reports they have rekindled their relationship.
While Gomez did not attend the ceremony herself, she is thought to have met him at the end, and the pair are said to have left the venue after Bieber's press photo call.
Selena is also thought to have met Taylor Swift for lunch the day after her alleged reunion meal with Justin, with an onlooker telling People they "shared an Italian meal and seemed to have the best time".
"There were a lot of giggles and laughter. They looked like great friends, and were also in deep conversation throughout the meal."
"Taylor was very protective of Selena and escorted her to and from the car."
Watch MTV News on the hour every hour on MTV - Sky Channel 126 and Virgin Channel 134